Since When Is “Protecting Women” from Making “Bad” Decisions Feminist?

Use quotes to search for exact phrases. Use AND/OR/NOT between keywords or phrases for more precise search results.

News Abortion

Since When Is “Protecting Women” from Making “Bad” Decisions Feminist?

Robin Marty

Thinking women aren't capable of making their own decisions, good or bad, is as unfeminist as you can get.

There has been a very distinct surge in anti-choice activism abroad, particularly in the United Kingdom and Canada.

The United Kingdom is now in the midst of its own 40 Days for Life protests, complete with the “sidewalk counseling” and graphic placards and signs synonymous with anti-choice activities here. Women’s rights and reproductive rights activists are pushing back, an effort that can be watched day by day at the 40 Days for Choice tumblr.

The media, however, appear to be doing some of the anti-choicers work for them by couching the effort to curtail reproductive freedom under the guise of feminism.

News Presenter Cathy Newman speaks with Maria Miller, the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport. Miller, who is in favor of reducing the limits for women seeking to terminate pregnancies, has recently been appointed Minister of Women.

Roe has collapsed in Texas, and that's just the beginning.

Stay up to date with The Fallout, a newsletter from our expert journalists.


In a Telegraph interview, Miller states that she supports reducing the legal limit for abortion from 24 weeks to 20 weeks, on the idea that feminism is about supporting women and she is “driven by that very practical impact that late term abortion has on women.”

It’s one thing for a member of the right leaning Conservative Party of Britain to try to equate a desire to protect women from their own actions as somehow being a feminist trait. But it’s one that Newman appears eager to accept.

Difficult as my decision was [to terminate a non-viable fetus], if the law changes, women in similar situations might not have the choice I did. On the other hand, I do appreciate the Miller/[Conservative politician Nadine] Dorries argument that the trauma of a late abortion, or terminating a potentially viable pregnancy may leave women with emotional scars which never fully heal.

It’s telling as a society that we find it necessary to debate whether or not protecting women from the alleged repercussions of their own decisions is feminist. For one thing,  reputable scientific studies have found no link between abortion and adverse mental health outcomes. And for another,  I can think of no other situation where we legislate restrictions on a medical procedure to save a patient from potential regret. Doing so in a way that specifically targets women is about as far from “feminist” as you can get.

Topics and Tags:

Access to abortion